Further attempt to change holiday homes into retirement village near Broughton Astley refused

A new attempt to create a retirement village on a go-kart track in the Harborough district has been refused.

Plans to create the retirement village on the Sutton Circuits go-karting track at Sutton Lane, in Sutton In The Elms, were attempted last year, but were dismissed on appeal after officers at Harborough District Council (HDC) raised concerns about the location.

That previous application, by David Poyner, looked to create a village for the over 50s, and was sent to appeal after HDC’s rejection, but a planning inspector sided with the council, raising multiple concerns, saying it was not in a “convenient” location.

The site, which is near Broughton Astley, has a long history of planning applications, including a 2021 application to build 45 woodland holiday lodges and a lake – a scheme which was approved.

A rough outline of the area which currently includes a go-karting facility Image: Google Earthplaceholder image
A rough outline of the area which currently includes a go-karting facility Image: Google Earth

A new attempt to create a retirement village on the site was put forward by Geoff Deacon this year, with his plans also including the creation of a lake, a shop and office with other additional buildings in relation to an adjacent golf club.

Plans note the original approved application included no more than 42 lodges (excluding the Manager’s lodge) and eight motor home spaces.

New plans would have seen the lodges turned into a retirement village for people aged 55 or over living in permanent residence. Mr Deacon’s plans also looked to turn the eight motorhome spaces into additional lodges.

The application states that the work has started but not completed.

There were four objections to the plans.

One said: “The site remains a karting track, and despite permission being granted over 10 years ago, there is no clear evidence that a holiday park has been delivered. This raises concern that a different form of development is being introduced without full planning scrutiny.”

They added: “This is not a minor amendment. The proposal fundamentally changes the development from holiday/leisure use to permanent housing. This goes beyond what a variation of conditions is intended to allow.”

In terms of traffic, they added: “It is important to remember that Sutton Lane is not a through road and has one exit point onto the Broughton Bypass. The carriageway is narrowed to a single lane in places because of significant on-street parking.

When consulted on the most recent plans, Leicestershire County Council, acting as the local highways authority (LHA), said the LHA was “satisfied that the traffic levels associated with the proposed development are unlikely to materially change as a result of the proposed change from holiday accommodation to a retirement community.”

However, officials on HDC disagreed and refused the scheme.

In a list of four reasons for their rejection, officials said: “The proposal would create permanent dwellings occupied by people aged 55+ as their sole or main residence in a countryside location which does not have convenient access to key services and facilities, and which fails to meet any of the specific criteria under which new dwellings in the countryside are allowed.”

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1854
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice