Planning inspector overrules Harborough District Council's decision on Hindu and Sikh crematorium plan

Plans for a Hindu and Sikh crematorium, which were rejected by Harborough District Council (HDC), can now be built, a planning inspector has ruled.

The development, at Scraptoft Lodge Farm in Keyham Lane, East Scraptoft, was turned down by HDC last April and divided opinion from the moment it was first unveiled.

The plan, from the CDS Group, looked to demolish a late 19th century farmhouse and outbuildings at Scraptoft Lodge Farm, in Keyham Lane, East Scraptoft and replace it with a crematorium.

A dining hall and car parking also form part of the plans which attracted 56 letters of support, but also gained 36 objections.

Proposed plans for a Hindu and Sikh crematorium, dining hall and car parking Image: pHp Architectsplaceholder image
Proposed plans for a Hindu and Sikh crematorium, dining hall and car parking Image: pHp Architects

The application was “called in” – meaning the decision was made at a planning meeting by councillors.

At the time, officers recommended refusal for the plan on the grounds that its location, scale, and design would disrupt the existing character of the surrounding area. HDC also believed the benefits associated with the proposed development would not outweigh this harm.

The CDS Group appealed against this decision, and a site visit with a government Planning Inspector took place on Tuesday, January 13.

Allowing the appeal, the Planning Inspector noted that the applicant had submitted revised plans which had not been part of the council’s decision making process, and made it clear that they had made their decision based on the plans originally submitted to the council, which were consulted upon.

Proposed plans for a Hindu and Sikh crematorium, dining hall and car parking Image: pHp Architectsplaceholder image
Proposed plans for a Hindu and Sikh crematorium, dining hall and car parking Image: pHp Architects

The inspector added: “The appeal process should not be used to evolve a scheme”.

Making their decision, the official said the combination of “modern, yet typical design would not be incompatible with the immediate or surrounding landscape”.

They added that, in the context of the overall site, the crematorium would “sit comfortably amongst generous grounds” and the building height would not be excessive.

In addition, they said the location, next to a burial ground, would be “complimentary to the local landscape”, rather than appearing out of place.

The Planning Inspector said the overall scale of the development would result in it being an “occasionally recognisable feature in the landscape”, which would be “well designed and sensitively sited”.

In conclusion, they said the development would have an acceptable effect on the character and appearance of the area, and in a “suitable location having regard to local and national policies that seek to control development in the countryside”.

Cllr Simon Galton, HDC’s cabinet lead for planning, said: “It is very disappointing that the Planning Inspector disagreed with both the council and local groups and residents that the development will cause landscape harm because of its scale; height of chimneys and choice of materials.

“We will work closely with the developer to ensure any development proceeds in accordance with conditions set out by the Planning Inspector allowing the appeal.”

The Local Democracy Reporting Service has asked Sanjiv Patel, on behalf of the Hindu community, for a comment on the plans.

News you can trust since 1854
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice